Goughnuts Large Stick vs. XL Ring: Which Extreme Chew Toy Is Right for Big Dogs?

Quick Answer

If your dog loves to fetch and chomp on a stick-shaped toy, the Goughnuts Large Stick (for dogs 60–120 pounds) is a great fit. If you prefer a ring for interactive fetch and a shape that's harder for some dogs to grip, the XL Ring (for dogs 100+ pounds) offers extreme durability for very large, aggressive chewers. Choose based on your dog's weight and play style.

When your dog is a serious chewer, finding a toy that lasts can feel like a never-ending quest. Goughnuts makes two popular options for big dogs: the Large Stick and the XL Ring. Both are built for tough chewers, but they serve different play styles and sizes.

In this comparison, we'll look at the key differences, what each toy is best for, and how to decide which one fits your dog's needs. We'll base everything on the official product details so you can make an informed choice.

What's the Difference Between the Large Stick and XL Ring?

The Goughnuts Large Stick is designed for medium and large-breed dogs weighing 60–120 pounds. It's engineer-designed and made from virtually indestructible material, built for long-lasting use. It's perfect for fetching and chomping, and it encourages activity and a healthy lifestyle.

The XL Ring is made for very large, extremely aggressive chewers, specifically dogs over 100 pounds. It's a natural rubber ring toy that's the most durable size and rubber Goughnuts offers. It's also great for interactive fetch and is a solid choice for tough and aggressive chewers.

• Consider your dog's weight: the Large Stick suits 60–120 pounds, while the XL Ring is for 100+ pounds.

Play Style: Fetch vs. Tug and Chew

The Large Stick is shaped like a classic stick, which many dogs love to carry, fetch, and chew on. It's a versatile toy that works well for games of fetch in the yard or park. The stick shape also gives dogs a satisfying surface to chomp on from different angles.

The XL Ring, on the other hand, has a ring shape that's easier for some dogs to grab and carry. It's also great for interactive fetch, but the ring design can make it harder for a dog to get a full grip, which can be a plus for preserving the toy. However, some dogs might prefer the stick shape for chewing.

• If your dog loves to fetch and carry, both work, but the stick shape may be more intuitive for some dogs.

Durability and Safety Considerations

Both toys are made from tough, durable materials. The Large Stick is virtually indestructible, and the XL Ring is the most durable size and rubber Goughnuts makes. That means the XL Ring is likely the better choice for the most extreme chewers, especially those over 100 pounds.

It's important to match the toy to your dog's size to avoid a toy that's too small and a choking hazard, or too large and unwieldy. The Large Stick is too large for most dogs, and the XL Ring is also too large for most dogs, so these are specifically for big breeds.

• Always supervise your dog with any chew toy and inspect it regularly for wear.

Trade-offs to Consider

• Size Range: Large Stick fits dogs 60–120 pounds; XL Ring is for dogs over 100 pounds. If your dog is under 100 pounds, the XL Ring may be too large. Match the toy to your dog's weight for safety and comfort.
• Shape and Play: Stick shape is great for fetch and chomping; ring shape is also fetch-friendly but may be harder for some dogs to grip, which can extend toy life. Think about what your dog enjoys: carrying a stick or chasing a ring.
• Durability Level: Both are durable, but the XL Ring is the most durable size and rubber Goughnuts makes, making it the top choice for the most aggressive chewers. For extreme chewers over 100 pounds, the XL Ring offers extra toughness.

Product Facts at a Glance

• Large Stick (for Dogs 60-120 Pounds) — Goughnuts: This stick toy is engineer-designed and made from virtually indestructible material. Built for long-lasting use. Ideal for medium and large-breed dogs who are very tough chewers. If your dog weighs between 60 and 120 pounds and loves to chew, this stick offers a durable, fetch-friendly option.
• XL Ring (for Dogs 100+ Pounds) — Goughnuts: A natural rubber ring toy designed to hold up to the toughest tough chewers. Our most durable size and rubber. For very large, extremely aggressive chewers. For dogs over 100 pounds with extreme chewing habits, this ring provides the highest level of durability in a shape that's great for fetch.

Which Toy Fits Your Dog?

Best for

• Dogs 60–120 pounds that love to fetch and chew on a stick-shaped toy
• Dogs that enjoy carrying a toy with a familiar stick shape

Not for

• Dogs under 60 pounds, as the toy may be too large and unwieldy
• Dogs over 100 pounds with extreme chewing habits, where the XL Ring offers more durability

Both the Goughnuts Large Stick and XL Ring are excellent choices for big dogs that chew hard. Choose the Large Stick if your dog is in the 60–120 pound range and loves a stick shape. Choose the XL Ring if your dog is over 100 pounds and needs the most durable option for aggressive chewing. Either way, you're getting a tough toy built to last.